Peer-to-peer Deaf Multiliteracies, 2017-2020

DOI

This project on multiliteracies involved groups of deaf learners in India, Uganda, and Ghana, both in primary schools and with young adult learners. The Peer-to-Peer Deaf Multiliteracies project examined how some of the dynamics that contribute to learners’ marginalisation can be changed by involving deaf individuals in the design of new teaching approaches, and by using children and young people's lived experiences and existing multilingual-multimodal skills as the starting point for theme-based learning. The aim was for participants to develop not only English literacy, but "multiliteracies", i.e. skills in sign languages, ICT, written English, creative expression through drawing and acting, and other forms of multimodal communication. The data collection includes reports from classroom settings compiled by tutors and by research assistants, pre-and post-tests on language and literacy abilities with learners, samples from an online learning platform, and multimedia portfolios collected from learners. A total of 124 young deaf adults and 79 deaf primary school children took part in the researchThe exclusion of deaf children and young adults from access to school systems in the developing world results in individuals and communities being denied quality education; this not only leads to unemployment, underemployment, low income, and a high risk of poverty, but also represents a needless waste of human talent and potential. To target this problem, this project extends work conducted under a pilot project addressing issues of literacy education with young deaf people in the Global South. Creating, implementing and evaluating our innovative intervention based on the peer teaching of English literacy through sign language-based tutoring, everyday real life texts such as job application forms, and the use of a bespoke online resource, enabled us to generate a sustainable, cost-effective and learner-directed way to foster literacy learning amongst deaf individuals. To reach further target groups and conduct more in-depth research, the present project extends our work to new groups of learners in India, Uganda, Ghana, Rwanda and Nepal, both in primary schools (ca 60 children in India, Ghana, and Uganda) and with young adult learners (ca 100 learners in interventions, plus ca 60 young adults in scoping workshops in Nepal and Rwanda). In the targeted countries, marginalisation begins in schools, since many have no resources for teaching through sign language, even though this is the only fully accessible language to a deaf child. This project intends to examine how we can change some of the dynamics that contribute to this, by involving deaf individuals in the design of new teaching approaches, and by using children and young people's everyday experiences and existing literacy practices as the basis for their learning. Participants in such a programme not only develop English literacy, but "multiliteracies", i.e. skills in sign languages, technology, written English, gesture, mouthing, and other forms of multimodal communication. Developing a multilingual toolkit is an essential element of multiliteracies. Being 'literate' in the modern world involves a complex set of practices and competencies and engagement with various modes (e.g. face-to-face, digital, remote), increasing one's abilities to act independently. Our emphases on active learning, contextualised assessments and building portfolios to document progress increases the benefit to deaf learners in terms of their on-going educational and employment capacity. Apart from the actual teaching and interventions, the research also investigates factors in existing systems of educational provisions for deaf learners and how these may systematically undermine and isolate deaf communities and their sign languages. Our analyses identify the local dynamics of cultural contexts that our programmes and future initiatives need to address and evaluate in order to be sustainable. One challenge we encountered in the pilot was the lack of trained deaf peer tutors. There is a need for investment in local capacity building and for the creation of opportunities and pathways for deaf people to obtain formal qualifications. Therefore, we develop training in literacy teaching and in research methods for all deaf project staff. We also develop and adapt appropriate assessment tools and metrics to confirm what learning has taken place and how, with both children and young adults. This includes adapting the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR) for young deaf adult learners and the 'Language Ladder' for deaf children so that we use locally-valid test criteria. To document progress in more detail and in relation to authentic, real life literacy demands we need to create our own metrics, which we do by using portfolio based assessments that are learner-centred and closely linked to the local curricula.

The Peer to Peer Deaf Multiliteracies project undertook interventions on language and literacy learning, with classes including primary school children as well as adults. The data that the project generated from both the children and adult learners include: a) language and literacy testing results, based on A1/A2 level of the Common European Framework of Reference for second language learning for adults, and on the English Language Ladder for children; b) multimedia portfolios compiled by the tutors showing monthly samples of the learners’ work; and c) text-based records of classes, namely reports written by tutors (monthly) and by research assistants (periodically). In addition, the data collection includes multimedia learning materials for language and literacy generated by the groups of learners with the tutors and posted on an online learning platform, as well as anonymous user statistics generated by the platform software. For working with children, the only sampling condition was an age range between 6-12 years of age. Within this age range, the project worked with groups of children as determined by the schools hosting the interventions. For young adults (with a maximum age limit of 35 years but the large majority in their 20s), prospective deaf candidates were selected by the local project teams based on interviews that established fluency in their local sign language and familiarity with the English alphabet.

Identifier
DOI https://doi.org/10.5255/UKDA-SN-854728
Metadata Access https://datacatalogue.cessda.eu/oai-pmh/v0/oai?verb=GetRecord&metadataPrefix=oai_ddi25&identifier=644945ba6830abf25fbc599fec7b697adfb5d49fbbd19a8a071b81d86dd027e6
Provenance
Creator Zeshan, U, University of Central Lancashire
Publisher UK Data Service
Publication Year 2021
Funding Reference Economic and Social Research Council
Rights Ulrike Zeshan, University of Central Lancashire. Julia Gillen, Lancaster University; The Data Collection is available to any user without the requirement for registration for download/access.
OpenAccess true
Representation
Resource Type Numeric; Text; Still image
Discipline Social Sciences
Spatial Coverage United Kingdom; India; Ghana; Uganda