Promoting language development in young children through shared reading, a randomised controlled trial 2015-2018

DOI

This is a randomised controlled trial of shared book reading with 150 children aged 2;6 to 3;0 which follows CONSORT guidelines. Dyads were randomly allocated to an intervention or control group. Parents in the intervention groups were be taught to read with their children using a particular reading style (dialogic reading or pause reading) and parents in the control group will be asked to read with their children but given no instruction on reading style. Dialogic reading was developed by Whitehurst et al. (1988) and is a style of reading which encourages the child to be the teller of the story and the adult to be the listener, questioner and audience of the child. The adult is trained to read with their child and to prompt them with questions and expand on their answers and praise them. Pause reading is a style of reading which involves pausing, recasting and open questioning. The adult is trained to pause when reading with their child and to ask them open questions and expand on their answers and praise them (Colmar, 2014). We assessed how the interventions were implemented by the parents across different SES groups, and how they affected children’s development of language skills. The three conditions were as follows: (1) Intervention 1: Group trained to read to their children using a dialogic reading style. (2) Intervention 2: Group trained to read to their children using a pause reading style. (3) Control: Reading control group and will receive no specific training. The intervention ran for six weeks and the parents were provided with books to read with their children. The parents were asked to read two books to their child five times a week.The most cost-effective way to tackle the root causes of many social and educational problems is to intervene early in children's lives, before the problems have had a chance to entrench. Key to this strategy is improving children's language development in the early years. Children who enter school with good language skills have better chances in school, better chances of entering higher education, and better economic success in adulthood. Reading is very effective at boosting children's language. Children who read regularly with their parents or carers tend to learn language faster, enter school with a larger vocabulary of words and become more successful readers in school. Because of this, local authorities often commission services to promote family-based shared book reading (e.g. the Bookstart programme). However, recent studies suggest that shared book reading interventions work less effectively for children from disadvantaged backgrounds than originally thought, particularly when their parents have lower levels of education. This means that there is a danger that the benefits of shared reading will be restricted to children from more affluent homes and not get through to those who need them most. To solve this problem, we need to develop a better understanding of how reading interventions work, and of how parents use them. We need to identify what parents do and say when reading aloud with their children and why this makes reading so effective at boosting children's language. We need to find out whether differences in how parents read mean that parents from disadvantaged backgrounds use these language boosting behaviours less frequently. We need to determine how to design interventions that increase the use of these behaviours in all parents, especially those with lower levels of education. Then, once we have identified how reading interventions work, we need to determine how to help parents use them successfully in their daily lives. The aim of this project is to determine how shared reading promotes child language development, and use this knowledge to make it an effective language boosting tool for children from all social and economic backgrounds. In Work Package 1, we will identify what language boosting behaviours parents use in shared reading, and will determine how parents from different social/economic backgrounds use these behaviours during shared reading. In Work Package 2, we will create four targeted interventions, each focussed on a particular language boosting behavior, and investigate how they are implemented by parents from different backgrounds, and how they affect children's language development. In Work Package 3, we will explore what influences parents' decisions to read or not to read with their children, in order to work out why parents may be unwilling to read with their children and to identify how to make reading a more enjoyable experience. We will also evaluate the benefits of a new intervention, designed by national charity The Reader Organisation, to promote reading for pleasure. Across the project, we will study a range of language skills, covering the core language abilities that are essential for learning to read and write in school. We will produce one review article, 9 original research articles, 30 conference presentations, and activities for non-academic audiences at local and national level. We will also submit a Cochrane review on the effectiveness of shared reading interventions for language development. Our results will enable health professionals such as health visitors, early years educators such as nursery school teachers, and policy-makers in local and national government to design targeted, cost-effective interventions to improve the language of children between the ages of 0 and 5 years. The work addresses ESRC's strategic priorities Influencing Behaviour: Informing Interventions and A Vibrant and Fair Society.

Recruitment and enrolment lasted 2 years 10 months between March 2015 and January 2018 and post-testing finished in March 2018. Eligible participants were monolingual children aged between 2;6 and 3;0 years living in the North-West of England. Exclusion criteria were, less than 37 weeks’ gestation, less than 5lbs 9oz at birth, prolonged and/or frequent ear infections, hearing another language (not English) for more than one day per week, children or parents who had a disability that prevented participation. There were 150 primary caregivers of which 10 were fathers, 2 were grandmothers and 1 was a childminder. Children were aged between 2;6 and 3;0 at the first visit (mean age = 32 months; SD = 2.07; range: 30 – 36 months) and 45% of children were female. The intervention ran for six weeks and the parents were provided with books to read with their children. The parents were asked to read two books to their child five times a week. Parents kept a reading diary and audio recorded shared book reading sessions with their child. Audio recordings were collected to assess compliance. Dyads attended a pre and post-intervention testing session. During these sessions we will collected a number of language measures: Standardised Language Assessments: (1) Preschool Language Scales - Fifth Edition (PLS-5). This is a published standardized measure of the language knowledge of individual children which contains the following sub scales; Auditory Comprehension and Expressive Communication. In the present study we used the raw score on the Auditory Comprehension subscale as a measure of language comprehension and the raw score on the Expressive Communication subscales as a measure of language production. We present the raw scores (2) The Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - Preschool 2 UK (CELF Preschool-2). This is a published standardized measure of the language knowledge of individual children. In the present study we used the ‘sentence structure’ subtest which assesses children’s comprehension of a range of simple and complex sentence structures. We present the raw scores. Naturalistic observations: The parent-child dyads played with toys for 10 minutes (toy play) and read books together for 10 minutes (shared reading). The order of the two activities was balanced across dyads. We collected video recordings of these sessions and we also transcribed a sample of these video recordings.

Identifier
DOI https://doi.org/10.5255/UKDA-SN-853383
Metadata Access https://datacatalogue.cessda.eu/oai-pmh/v0/oai?verb=GetRecord&metadataPrefix=oai_ddi25&identifier=07c7a3544a5764119fc54e8831bcfcdf0463b705aa4853fc4fcd3488def39a2a
Provenance
Creator Rowland, C, University of Liverpool; Noble, C, University of Liverpool; Sawyer, H, University of Liverpool; Taylor-Ims, R, University of Liverpool; Coates, A, University of Liverpool
Publisher UK Data Service
Publication Year 2019
Funding Reference Economic and Social Research Council
Rights Caroline Rowland, University of Liverpool; The Data Collection is available for download to users registered with the UK Data Service.
OpenAccess true
Representation
Language English
Resource Type Audio; Numeric; Video
Discipline Psychology; Social and Behavioural Sciences
Spatial Coverage Merseyside; United Kingdom